Started playing magic with Portal and Mirage. Currently play historic and looking to get into Modern.
60% for Bant Nadu with that many games is insane imo. This is after a short time since MH3 came out too, not sure what that’s going to be once it gets played more and more.
There’s no doubt in my mind Nadu eats a Hogaak style ban too. Way overpowered and way too much representation.
I also honestly still think The One Ring needs to go too. That card is bonkers level nuts and I think it’s being slightly overshadowed by the even more nuts Nadu.
I just want to say I think we’re lucky to have Corey Baumeister and his commentary! I could listen to this guy 24 hours a day.
Looking at the full decklist, damn I think you would have 3-0’d this even without any!
This is hilarious, I think I’d play 10 if I saw them all 😛
I totally agree. In this video one of the guys basically says whenever he sees a turn 1 Grief->Reanimate->Grief or an Initiative creature he just scoops and decides its not worth playing that game. I get that this on the extreme side, but when you have players activity deciding to just scoop instead of playing out a game, because of how mentally exasperating it is, I wonder what the f- are we even doing! This is a GAME. This screams to me local/community ban list. I were running a store and trying to get people to come out, I would just manage my own banlist, but a community created one would go the furthest I think.
I don’t play Legacy but I’ve always been a big fan of the format. It’s very interesting to hear their thoughts on how negatively impactful Grief has been for the format. I think it’s frustrating but expected that Wizards delays banning a card from the current active set that they’re promoting. They haven’t even shipped out Gift Bundles yet (July) so to ban a card from the set before people even receive the product is definitely never happening.
I do think that Grief creates non-games, and I think non-games are truly antithetical to “fun” and fun should be the #1 concern for every game in existence. The fact that they’re not banning it means they care more about money than fun.
I think they quietly renamed Historic Brawl to “Brawl” and then Brawl became “Standard Brawl”. That’s just from what I’ve seen online but I don’t if that’s formal or anything.
I think The One Ring has been slipping under the radar with all the focus on Nadu. Nadu is definitely a problem but The One Ring is being run in nearly every other deck and I just cannot see how this is a good thing for any format. If aggro, midrange, combo, and control are all running the same card I think that’s a clear sign the card is not only too strong, but too easy to run as well.
There just aren’t any downsides, not even color pips, to prevent auto-including it and the upside is to high that it’s often the right decision to just run 4 of them. I saw a number of games in PT MH3 where the game was almost over but the player behind casts TOR and then ends up winning from the card advantage it generated.