1
Community Pruning - TwoXChromosomes (!twoxchromosomes) - SLRPNK
slrpnk.netAs outlined in the SLRPNK Rules
[https://wiki.f-hub.org/books/slrpnknet/page/lemmy-instance], any member of this
instance can create communities, but doing so comes with responsibilities: *
Active moderation of communities you create (you can add additional moderators
yourself though) * Please add a community avatar and a basic side-bar text
explaining what the community is about * Make a short introduction post to tell
us a bit about yourself and why you created this community (this is mandatory!)
Occasionally we prune communities that do not meet these requirements. I’ve
reached out to both current moderator accounts via PM, and neither
GreatWhiteBuffalo41 [https://slrpnk.net/u/greatwhitebuffalo41] or
Justincase_2008@lemmy.world [https://lemmy.world/u/Justincase_2008] have replied
or shown any activity on SLRPNK in 5 months or more. We often prune communities
without public comment, but in this case we felt it deserved special mention. #
A Brief History of Reddit’s TwoXChromosomes When Reddit started, its primary
archetype was Slashdot [https://slashdot.org/], a site whose tagline was “News
for Nerds” and whose format included voting on comments, user-assisted
moderation, and user submitted stories for the admins to directly sign-off on,
but the categories for posts were admin controlled. When Reddit started, one of
its early communities was Programming [https://www.reddit.com/r/programming/],
which remained a regular presence on the front page even after Reddit changed
its architecture to allow user-created communities. Both Slashdot and to a
lesser extent Reddit continue to be heavily male-dominated spaces and toxic to
women. A common justification for this toxic dynamic was that there was
something about STEM other than the male fragility, hostility, and domination
that caused the lopsided representation. Into this milieu appeared
TwoXChromosomes [https://www.reddit.com/r/TwoXChromosomes/] - the name was
catchy and immediately conjured both womanhood and tech-savvy, educated, nerdy
fun. Posts from this community quickly became a regular fixture of Reddit’s
front page, demonstrating an outpouring of demand for a threaded discussion
forum for women interested in technology and science. But the victory was not
effortless; complaining about 2XC became a favorite pastime for fragile men on
the site. As their minority community grew, they had to constantly deal with men
wanting to re-hash long-settled debates, have toxic masculinity personally
explained to them, and other kinds of bad-faith engagement – in addition to the
undisguised harassment. 2XC instituted a heavy-handed (for the time) moderation
policy that allowed men to participate, but only if they respected the community
as a women’s space. This represented one of the earliest and largest online
spaces that participated in a larger discussion platform while protecting its
minority members. For that reason 2XC was a trailblazer when it came to
protected online spaces. # Is TwoXChromosomes Transphobic? This was an early
concern arising from the name, and the gender-essentialist attacks against
transgender women. The early moderators of 2XC took the controversial (in 2008)
stance that trans-women are women, and committed to be a trans-inclusive space
[https://www.reddit.com/r/TwoXChromosomes/comments/9283g/addressing_the_genetics_issue_you_dont_have_to_be/].
Trans-women were added as moderators, and trans-women’s issues were frequently
included in the topics of discussion. All women were shielded by the mods from
male harassment, and trans-exclusionary women were not welcome
[https://www.reddit.com/r/TwoXChromosomes/comments/fejj7u/mini_faq_do_i_have_to_be_a_woman_to_participate/].
[https://slrpnk.net/pictrs/image/95574ffb-74ac-4683-8b4f-7a6318883fbf.webp]
Still, some trans-women and their allies felt excluded by the name, and for good
reason. Defining femininity based on what chromosomes and how many one has is
more than a dog-whistle - it’s a naked form of aggression towards all women. But
I’d argue that by normalizing “two x-chromosomes” as a synecdoche for all women
rather than a bigoted attack, the community name is furthering the cause of
transgender people. # How did the Fediverse’s 2XC become unmoderated? The
activity-pub version of 2XC was created in June 2023
[https://slrpnk.net/post/415853] during the height of the first Reddit exodus.
The creator established it with the intention of carrying on Reddit 2XC’s
legacy, and was soon joined by a mod from Reddit’s 2XC. They were quickly
challenged by members of the transgender community about the name, but most
significantly, were overwhelmed by eager participation by inconsiderate men. On
Reddit, TwoXChromosomes typically is dominated by self-posts, where women are
seeking validation from other women, or want to hear women’s opinions on news or
ideas. AP-2XC quickly became a place for men to come and seek validation from
women, share their opinions on women’s issues, or debate women about their
opinions. The original AP-2XC mods called out for additional moderators, but
couldn’t find women interested in sharing the responsibility to bring AP-2XC
closer to the standards set by the original. Both mods have since returned to
being active on Reddit. # Is the Fediverse hostile to women? Yes, obviously. But
not more than Slashdot, Reddit, or other similar platforms. I hope in the future
on this platform or somewhere else in the Fediverse, a group of women will pick
up the mantle of 2XC again and build a community better than its template. This
set-back should serve as a reminder that the fight for women’s spaces online
isn’t over. They require above-average tending by committed moderators, or any
new minority space is likely to experience the same fate. As admins, we
procrastinated longer than we probably should have to close AP-2XC. We had hoped
that it would find new champions, and could eventually make a full recovery. We
were hesitant to step in and moderate in their stead, based on the land-mines
inherent in men trying to moderate women’s spaces. Leaving the 2XC unmoderated
creates a situation where new female participants are quickly chased away by the
heavy male participation, and each new visitor is given the false impression
that SLRPNK, (or worse) the Fediverse, is devoid of women. Both Blahaj.zone
[https://lemmy.blahaj.zone/] and Beehaw [https://beehaw.org/] have done a great
job of creating protected spaces for women, and are pushing for more moderators
and better software support to improve their record. At SLRPNK, we’re eager to
also create healthy spaces for women, and are talking over XMPP about the best
way to move forward with that. # Watch here for updates We usually close
unmoderated communities, but in the case of TwoXChromosomes, we plan to disable
public posting and lock all threads. New participants will be redirected to this
thread, and when the situation changes, we will post here with updates. I’d like
to thank the Activity Pub-2XC moderators for attempting this task, and for
choosing SLRPNK as the place to try it. I’d also like to thank the women and
non-binary people who participated in our disappointing simulacrum of 2XC
despite its failings, and to men from SLRPNK and other more progressive corners
of the Fediverse, who I feel helped push back against the waves of toxic and
less enlightened men who dominated the community. We’re always looking for more
moderators from among SLRPNK members, and there are a number of other
communities that are undermoderated. If you enjoy a community’s existence,
consider joining the XMPP chat on Movim [https://movim.slrpnk.net], people are
eager to accept whatever help you can give.
This community is being pruned. If you would like to discuss this, please comment in the !meta post.
You must log in or register to comment.