I summed it up in my response to them, but essentially they have a confused idea of what Communism even means. It’s perfectly possible for them to have grown up in a Communist nation, but 2 points stick out as confused:
They believe Communism structurally depends on “good people not being selfish” without elaborating, and
They believe Communism to be about some vague “equality,” despite Marx arguing against said very notion.
Agreed, but I am sad that they don’t choose to share any of those personal experiences that they claim are vital for understanding communism.
Even if communist revolutions tend to fail for the same reasons most revolutions fail (a need for temporary authoritarian rule followed by fumbling the succession) anything that can help understand how and why something failed is useful.
The fact that people are downvoting you and saying no no you didn’t actually live through that is fucking crazy
I summed it up in my response to them, but essentially they have a confused idea of what Communism even means. It’s perfectly possible for them to have grown up in a Communist nation, but 2 points stick out as confused:
They believe Communism structurally depends on “good people not being selfish” without elaborating, and
They believe Communism to be about some vague “equality,” despite Marx arguing against said very notion.
Removed by mod
Agreed, but I am sad that they don’t choose to share any of those personal experiences that they claim are vital for understanding communism.
Even if communist revolutions tend to fail for the same reasons most revolutions fail (a need for temporary authoritarian rule followed by fumbling the succession) anything that can help understand how and why something failed is useful.
Why?
For a revolution to succeed you need the power to remove any people in power that oppose you, doesn’t get more authoritarian than that.
This is why
authoritarianism is infinitely preferable to authoritarianism + communism + famine + repression of speech etc etc